Cisco Wireless :: Setting Up Aironet 1040 Access Point

I'm working on setting up an Aironet 1040 Wireless Access Point for my company.  It's my first time setting up something like this, and I've run into a bit of trouble.
 
I created my first SSID easily enough, following the manual and guides online.  I set up VLAN 1 as my native VLAN and linked it to my SSID with the encryption and security that I was told to use and it works great.  However, my boss asked me to set up a second connection as well for guests at the office, and this is where my trouble starts.
 
I created VLAN 2, and then another SSID which I linked here.  I set up encryption and security the same way, and I can see the network when I open up my network and sharing manager.  I can connect to the network as well, but I either get a spinning blue icon where my signal strength indicator is or a few bars with a yellow caution sign, and Windows says 'Identifying...'.  I've compared the two SSIDs using the console and the GUI and I can't seem to spot any obvious differences between them.